SciFi Diner Podcast Ep. 166
The Science Fiction Quandary: Keith R.A. DeCandido,
Jim Arrowood, and Raul Ybarra Join Us To Solve The Dilemma
The SciFi Diner Podcast
A 2012 Parsec Finalist
Please call the listener line at 1.888.508.4343,
Email us at firstname.lastname@example.org
or visit us on Twitter @scifidiner.
And check out our YouTube channel.
Welcome to the Diner.
If you have listened to the show for sometime, we would love to have you leave feedback on iTunes. We know not all of you use iTunes, but for those that do, it helps us become more visible. If you don’t use iTunes, your feedback is still valuable. Visit our webpage at http://scifidinerpodcast.com and leave a comment on the show notes or email us at email@example.com We want to know what you are thinking about what we are saying and what shows you are watching.
Discussion: What is SciFi?
Trivia Question: We know Tony Amendolo for his work on Stargate SG1 & now recently Continuum. What Star Trek sereis did Tony Amendolo guest star in?
The Prize: The Star Trek 12 Poster plus the latest Star Trek: Faragut DVD
Winner: Congratulations to Judi the Polish Blonde!
You will have until March 19th to send us your answers. Please include the code word mentioned in the first 15 minutes of the show. Send your answer with your mailing address to firstname.lastname@example.org, call us at 18885084343, or DM us on Twitter at @scifidiner. Make sure you include your e-mail with all entries! Only one entry per person. The SciFi Diner is not responsible for any injuries occurring if you secretly decide to go all shiny and dress in a browncoat and walk into your local bar.
Join Keith R.A. DeCandido, Jim Arrowood, Raul Ybarra, Miles and Scott as they wrestle with what science fiction is and try to come to a common understanding of what it is. Throughout our discussion, we tackle the issue, what makes its so difficult to define, the whole Science Fiction versus Fantasy, whether Star Wars is Science Fiction, and hear from some of you as well.
If you want to find out more about our panelists, check out their links below!
Raul Ybarra’s site: Welcome to the Christian Geek. It’s pretty safe to say that this will not be your typical blog. Tech, gadgets, sci-fi and geekery in general are welcome here as well as Christian thought and perspectives. Though you don’t often see them together, there is no reason why they shouldn’t mix.
Jim Arrowood’s Blog: As he says, “The purpose of this blog is to have a little fun. It is NOT to start arguments. I don’t profess to be an expert on Sci-fi, nor do I aspire to become an expert. You are welcome to comment on any and all content you find here. If my opinion differs from yours, as far as I am concerned, it’s all okay. I will never say that you are wrong because you disagree with me, and I expect the same from those that comment here. Posts will hopefully be regular based on the movies I see, the television shows I watch, and the books I read as well as what ever strikes me as noteworthy.
The SciFi Five In Five
After giving it some thought, here are my personal Fringe top 5. I can’t call it moments, because some of these are obviously not moments. I guess the best way to describe them are the 5 most outstanding things about Fringe.
5. Season 5: For two reasons. 1) That it happened at all. 2) that a series be allowed so much time for a real denouement is incredibly rare and Fringe pulled it off successfully.
4. The number 4 spot is a tie. The choices don’t out rank my higher spots, but neither does either bump number 5 off the list. The first one is when Newton restores Walter’s missing brain pieces in the season 2 episode Grey Matters. The Walter we see there is a defining moment for the character. We see the 1970’s Walter, Waltenate and 2036 Walter all rolled into one.
The other is the season 4 episode, A Short Story About Love. Olivia makes the choice between which Olivia she is going to be. Not only is this unique character development, but it is a clear message that both timelines happened and both are relevant.
3. The Episode, Peter. Speaking as a father, this one just cuts my heart out. How many dads listening would not take Walter’s path if they had that ability? Fatherhood is an important theme in Fringe and this episode is the key one establishing it.
2. White Tulip. Not just the episode, but the symbol. Walter’s conversation with Alister Peck alone would be justification for this list, but the show went so much further. It comes back several times over the course of the show and its appearance as the concluding moment of series is one of the best endings in television.
1. The World Trade Center. The pull back revealing the Twin Towers in season 1 was one the most Oh, my God moments I’ve seen in television. Few writers would dare take the chance to go that route. That was the moment it became clear that this wasn’t just a good show, but that we were in for something *very* special. And Fringe did not disappoint.
The song at the end of the episode is below: